barkbox vs pupbox

Barkbox vs Pupbox: Which Dog Subscription Box Is the Best?

Great, your dog just ate the newspaper, and you haven’t even sat down for breakfast yet. Stop your furry friend from feasting on your furniture and fixings with a dog subscription box service.

A dog subscription box service gives your pup a fresh batch of chews and treats each month and a few toys to occupy them during the day.

You’ll never catch Fido chewing away on your slippers or newspaper when they have toys lying around.

This review compares Barkbox vs Pupbox in the quest to see which subscription box is the better choice for your dog or puppy.

We’ll unpack everything you need to know about these two services, giving you the chance to make an informed purchase decision for your pooch.

We recommend Barkbox.....

barkbox reviews

Barkbox offers an exceptional combination of quality, price, and convenience.  


  • Suitable for dogs of all ages.
  • Options for classic toys or “Super Chewer” toys.
  • More affordable than Pupbox.
  • Themed boxes
  • $45 of toys and treats in every box.
  • Barkbox donates 5% of profits to supporting animal organizations.


  • Barkbox donates 5% of profits to supporting animal organizations.

Our Barkbox vs Pupbox Verdict:

If you’re looking for one subscription box service for your dog, we recommend going with Barkbox. While puppies can enjoy the toys that come with Barkbox, adult dogs won’t find much entertainment in the toys included with a Pupbox.

Barkbox has the most versatile offering, and it's more affordable than Pupbox. The lifetime guarantee on the Super Chewer toys and the high-quality treats and chews included with your Barkbox make it the ideal choice for your furry friend.

What Is Pupbox?

Pupbox is a new subscription box service aimed at puppies. Co-founded by Ariel and Ben Zvaifler in 2014, Pupbox grossed $275,000 in its first year of business, more than doubling that to $700,000 in 2016.

The co-founders appeared on season eight of “The Shark Tank” in a quest to gain more funding for the expansion of the business. The Pupbox shark tank collaboration was a hit, with the company expecting to grow its sales to over $2-million per year with the Shark Tank investors.

Pupbox is different from the subscription box service because it targets puppy owners. When the co-founders arrived at the Shark Tank show, they brought puppies to melt the shark's hearts – a genius strategy that worked out well for the pair.

Pupbox Pros and Cons

pupbox logo


  • Designed specifically with puppies in mind.
  • Dedicated training materials.


  • Not suitable for adult dogs.
  • More expensive than Barkbox.
  • No box theme

What Is Barkbox?

Barkbox is one of the originators of the dog subscription box service. Founded in 2011 by Carly Strife, Henrik Werdelin, and Matt Meeker, the company is now the market leader, shipping boxes to more than 2-million dogs worldwide.

Barkbox focuses on providing your dog with premium-quality toys and treats that entertain them during the month.

Each month, you receive a new box with a distinct theme, filled with toys and treats for your dog. Barkbox offers you a standard version for your average dog or the “Super Chewer” box for dogs that love chewing.

Barkbox offers a Lifetime guarantee on its toys, and if your dog destroys them, you can send them back to Barkbox for a replacement.

What comes in a Pupbox?

Every month, Pupbox ships you a new box with toys and treats for your pup. The package focuses on training guides and tools to help you train your pup. Each month, you get a training guide suited to your puppy's age.

You can expect to find the following inside your Pupbox.

  • Monthly training guides.
  • One bag of treats.
  • 4 to 6 additional items, including toys and grooming products.

Each Pupbox comes with goodies worth more than $40. You get free shipping on your box, directly to your doorstep.

Barkbox vs Pupbox – What comes in a Barkbox?

Each month, Barkbox ships you a new box with a specific theme, like “Fairground Hounds” and “Dogsgiving.” The theme is cute, setting the tone for what you can expect inside the box.

Each Barkbox comes with the following items.

  • Two Meaty Chews in chicken, beef, or turkey flavors.
  • Two bags of treats in various flavors.
  • One chew toy.

If you have a breed that likes to chew, consider signing up for the Super Chewer subscription. With this box, you get an extra durable chew toy for an additional $8 a month on the annual plan. Your Barkbox comes with free shipping to your doorstep.

Barkbox vs Pupbox – What’s the Price Difference

Barkbox Review

Barkbox is considerably more affordable than Pupbox with its six-month and 12-month plans. However, the monthly subscription is more expensive than Pupbox.

Barkbox offers you the following subscription tiers.

  • 1 Month Subscription $35
  • 6 Month Subscription $26
  • 12 Month Subscription $23

Pupbox Review

Pupbox is cheaper than Barkbox on its monthly plan, but that’s about it. The yearly and six-month plans from Barkbox are significantly more affordable than the Pupbox subscription.

Pupbox comes with the following subscription tiers.

  • 1 Month Subscription $29
  • 3 Month Subscription $32
  • 6 Month Subscription $34
  • 12 Month Subscription $39

Fortunately, we help you get 50% off Your First Pupbox on any plan, use the Pupbox coupon code “PUPPY50” when you check out.

How Do I Start with Pupbox or Barkbox?

Starting with Pupbox or Barkbox is easy. Navigate to the official company website, and click the sign-up button.

The systems AI takes you through a quiz designed to get to know your dog. After completing a brief questionnaire on your dog or puppy, the AI decides what toys and treats to send your dog. The tech makes its decision based on the information you provide and top products for your dog.

After that, choose your subscription plan, and wait for your first box to arrive. Both companies ship you your first box after making your payment, and the companies send all concurrent packages on the 15th of each month.

Frequently Asked Questions

What monthly dog box is the best?

We recommend Barkbox for adult dog owners and Pupbox for puppy owners. Barkbox also comes with the “Super Chewer” option, which we think is a marvelous idea for owners of breeds that love to chewy.  If you have an Alsatian or Pitbull with powerful jaws and an appetite for your slippers or furniture, sign them up for the Super Chewer subscription.

Is Pupbox worth the money?

Yes, if you have a puppy, Pupbox is a great subscription service. Each month you receive a training idea, toys, and treats for your pup, keeping them interested and engaged with their development.  Pupbox gives you twice the value in your box that you pay for with your subscription, making it worth your while.

Is Pupbox the same as Barkbox?

No, Pupbox and Barkbox are entirely different companies with no affiliation with each other. Pupbox caters to puppy owners, offering them a subscription box for puppies.  Barkbox is a subscription box service, but it only caters to adult dogs. Pupbox is slightly more expensive than Barkbox and comes with different toys and products included with your subscription.

What’s the difference between Barkbox vs Chewy?

Chewy is a general pet store offering everything from food to toys to medicine for your animals. They work with all types of pets, including dogs, cats, fish, reptiles, and more.  Barkbox only caters to adult dogs. There are no options for puppies, or any other animals, like cats. Chewy offers you a Goodie box for your dog or cat, with options for large, medium, or small dogs or puppies. Barkbox only has options for adult dogs.

barkbox reviews

Barkbox Special Offer

Check out our SPECIAL OFFER for a free dog toy with a subscription purchase.  

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top